eCAFE - Course and Faculty Evaluation, University of Hawaii

eCAFE: Course and Faculty Evaluations


Instructor: Baybars Karacaovali

Available Survey Results

ECON321, Fall 2013
ECON362, Fall 2013
ECON362A, Spring 2013
ECON660, Spring 2013
ECON362, Fall 2012
ECON460, Fall 2012
ECON321, Spring 2012
ECON460, Fall 2011

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON321, Fall 2013

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 321 - Introduction to Statistics Crn (Section): 70796 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.27 91 0.88 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 17 (19%) 37 (41%) 31 (34%) 2 (2%) 2 (2%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.77 91 0.42 Freq(%) 20 (22%) 67 (74%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.72 91 0.47 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (1%) 23 (25%) 66 (73%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.57 91 0.6 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (5%) 29 (32%) 56 (62%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.34 91 0.83 Freq(%) 1 (1%) 3 (3%) 6 (7%) 35 (38%) 46 (51%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.18 91 0.97 Freq(%) 3 (3%) 2 (2%) 11 (12%) 34 (37%) 40 (44%)
7. I deepened my interest in the subject matter of this course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
3.74 91 1.18 Freq(%) 6 (7%) 5 (5%) 27 (30%) 22 (24%) 31 (34%)
8. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
Professor Baybars is a great professor and knows what he is talking about. He is willing to help when he is available.
The homework and lecture handouts.
The problem sets were very helpful in understanding concepts covered in lecture.
Dr. Baybars is very understanding and accommodating. He makes sure that his students learn the material and teaches the material at a manageable pace. His homework is designed to strengthen the student's understanding of the material. The midterm was challenging but not too difficult. Overall an excellent class. I learned a lot.
I think that the in-class lectures were most vital in my learning, especially the in class examples with the i-Clickers.
Hypothesis testing and probability
The handouts helped me follow along with his lectures
everything
Homework assignments
The applications of mathematics in economics and in real world situations.
The problem sets and quizzes helped me gain comprehension of the material and helped me prepare for the tests.
Good teaching skills and friendly
It was really helpful be able to go in for help and to have practice exam questions for the midterm and final.
Problem set explanations
everything from the homework, lectures, computer assignments were well planned out. looked forward to going to lectures, very fun class.
learning how to use excel was valuable
understanding what statistics is and the importance of it
I feel that all aspects of this course contributed equally. Still, I particularly enjoyed the computer assignments since we were given "raw" data, ran our own tests, and came up with statistical conclusions (and implications) - such experience will be invaluable in the future when interpreting our own research data in our given fields.
His notes and lectures are very informative and clear.
The notes and the handouts provided by professor karacaovali really helped me understand what we were learning.
The homework assignments with the solutions were the most valuable to my understanding of the course
The handouts
Applying what was learned in class to homework assignments, quizzes, and exams.
probability of actions
the handouts and the equation sheet for the test
doing quizes, homework and computer assignments.
I appreciated the availability of solutions for review.
First half of semester on basic stats
Graphs Problem Sets Sample midterm and exams
Hypothesis testing and confidence intervals
He never rushes the class. Even though there are almost 100 students, he seems to try to check every student understand and catch the class well. That is very impressive and I think it helps at least me a lot.
The professor gives many chances to earn points towards grade. Was also understanding that not all students learn at the same pace and from time to time asked if we needed any clarification.
The problem sets are pretty useful because it let me understand the topic by doing this and at least I get some practices.
Professor Baybars is a wonderful professor! He is always willing to help and ensures that the students understand the content thoroughly. He always offers help and advises us to come in during office hours if we need extra assistance.
I noticed that a lot of the things I learned related to scholarly biology journals.
That the information can be used in real life
I think a lot of the problem sets were helpful especially for someone who is going into a science career. I thought the hypothesis testing and probability topics were most valuable. I also thought that the computer assignments were helpful in connecting these topics to doing something that I would probably use in the future.
I really thought learning probablity was very helpful
The computer assignments were a great idea but we could have done more to learn about statistics through excel and other programs.
His examples were of situations i could see using in the future.
I think that he was very approachable and easy to learn from. He made the topic fun with interesting examples and it was good that participation was required. But I think that he should have more frequent shorter assignments rather than once every week or two having a large assignment and that way we can stay tuned into what we are talking about becasue it is very easy to forget.
I like having homework and participation/attendance points available to help cushion the overall course grade.
I enjoyed the handouts to follow the teachers teachings.
all
Certain lessons.
the new skills i learned
The professor was very well organized. The most organized professor I have ever had.
Going over the different theories of statistics.
Going over the problem sets in class and using them for studying for the quiz(s).
I really appreciated the solving of problems on the screen so we could visually and mentally follow how to work problems out.
Understanding that statistics you see in the media don't always accurately depict the feelings of the public.
Learning the math and theory behind statistical tests was very valuable.
we are able to take the knowledge learned from this course and apply it to real life statistics
Hypothesis testing because it will be useful for lab and in the future!
I liked the handouts, they were super helpful
He provides lot of material and assignments that make sure we get a grasp on the subject matter. Also, lots of opportunities to help our grade.
The handouts, formula sheets, and computer assignments were helpful.
Homework, iclicker, and lectures
I really liked how Professor Karacaovali spent a good amount of time on each concept introduced to the class. He taught us at a good rate that made it simpler for us to follow along and understand the concepts.
The problem sets and examples done in class. This helped a lot with understanding the material.
Probability
I love Professor Karacaovali's accent. Very soothing.
The detailed explanations of how things work and why we are using certain tets versus others.
statistics
It is well organized.
Content
I liked how the assignment were posted online
9. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
Even though Baybars thoroughly knows every subject we learned in class, I feel as though he went through each subject way too fast, I couldn't keep up with everything going on. But if you set up an appointment with him, he is much more thorough and is excellent at explaining the subject one on one.
Professor sometimes didn't know what he was talking about as he would have long pauses and say he'd get back to it later. Lectures weren't thoroughly taught.
NA overall was a very good course
N/A
I did not learn that much from the computer assignments. The assignments were essentially how well I could follow instructions.
Computer assignments; while the assignments were relatively simple, they did not deepen my understanding of the statistical concepts covered in class.
The computer assignments
none
N/A
I didn't like the computer assignments, because i had a hard time doing them with my Mac. Also, none of those aspects were on the exams and i had a difficult time understanding what the point of all of it was.
Computer exercises
nothing, everything was valuable and fun at the same time.
N/A
All was valuable.
n/a
tghe computer assignments because when all the steps are continuously given to you it does not give the student an incentive to study/memorize how to perform these operations. It would have been better if the statistics were just already given to us and we have to answer the questions.
Computer assignments
z scoring
the quizzes
Computer Assignments
None
Computer assignments iClicker questions Quizzes
Not really.
n/a
I guess maybe the computer assignments because we just have to follow the instruction and get the answer. Although it is a easy homework, I do not get anything from doing it.
I don't think there was anything least valuable.
nothing
I thought all aspects of the class were valuable.
Everything taught in the class is valuable!
Some of the advanced parts of the class i could not see how i could use in the future. He would fulfill the teaching of how to do a problem but fail to provide good real life examples which help me with understanding.
I had a hard time with the structure of the handouts. I like the idea of it; however, the structure and content on them made it a little hard to study - especially if I missed a day.
N/a
none
Things that I could grasp.
none
N/A
The midterm format. I would have preferred a handout and answer sheet, possibly multiple choice rather than drawing tables and graphs in a book, which was very time consuming.
Some of the concepts of confidence intervals were hard to understand.
The beginning part of the course was a little too easy and it did not seem necessary to spend so much time on it.
some of the material was vague and rushed, as the professor thought each student was knowledgable prior to the lecture. when some of the students in the class was seeing the material for the first time.
The first 6 lectures because in college we should not have to go over how to find the mean median and range. You learn that stuff in middle school maybe even elementary school!!!!!
The computer assignments
The iclicker questions we a distraction at times from the flow of the course.
There was no aspects of this course that wasn't valuable.
nothing.
The painstaking detail to every question. Grante, some may not understand, but we are in college and if they need additional help, they need to seek that out rather than slow the entire class. The I-clicker use, while it sounds like a good idea, does not work well. It seems to waste more time than necessary. Good PPT slides, but running back and forth through them to point out a particular number, just disrupts the flow of the class.
The harsh penalties for missing a class.
Teaching methodology
I thought everything went fine. Everything was important.
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.33 91 0.72 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 13 (14%) 34 (37%) 43 (47%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.62 91 0.53 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (2%) 31 (34%) 58 (64%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.39 91 0.76 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 2 (2%) 9 (10%) 31 (34%) 48 (53%)
13. The TA gives clear and understandable explanations.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.76 91 1.02 Freq(%) 2 (2%) 4 (4%) 28 (31%) 21 (23%) 23 (25%) 13 (14%)
14. The TA appears to have a thorough knowledge of the subject.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.86 91 0.93 Freq(%) 1 (1%) 1 (1%) 31 (34%) 21 (23%) 25 (27%) 12 (13%)
15. The TA grades paper (exams, homework) fairly.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
4.57 91 0.64 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 7 (8%) 24 (26%) 58 (64%) 2 (2%)
16. The TA was easy to talk with and available for consultation.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
4.1 91 0.86 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 3 (3%) 18 (20%) 30 (33%) 32 (35%) 8 (9%)
17. The TA's oral speaking was clear and effective.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.88 91 0.9 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 6 (7%) 22 (24%) 34 (37%) 24 (26%) 4 (4%)
18. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.44 91 0.82 Freq(%) 1 (1%) 1 (1%) 10 (11%) 24 (26%) 55 (60%)
19. Other comments:
TA was barely present.
Such a great class! It took a reasonably boring subject and made it interesting. It helped deepen my understanding of statistics and I think it has provided me with a good foundation for my future in Economics.
n/a
I recommend this teacher to my friends
Great teacher that uses real life, interesting examples in homework and lectures.
It's obvious that Professor Karacaovali knows the material and is very knowledgeable but he doesn't teach well. The class is very dull and although it started off fairly easy it became difficult and was hard to understand because it moved at a fast pace. I also know a lot of my classmates found the material difficult to understand but because a select few have aced the midterm, it was assumed it must not be his teaching but our learning that was the problem.
it was a great class to take. really enjoyed it.
it would have been helpful if the professor posted the slides online after each class, or used a book.
professor k. was an amazing instructor. his slides were the best i have seen, you can tell he spent a considerable amount of time on them but was well worth the effort. it makes paying attention much easier to a dry subject like statistics. he was very humorous which also helped a lot. The homework assignments were very well done, he was able to use real world examples making learning even easier when its relate-able to life so you dont get the feeling "when am i ever going to use this." his use of tech with the i clicker and solving problems right in front of us over the computer was awesome too. and his accent is bad ass.
I think the instructor should change his teaching methods to better explain things to people who are not strong in math. I actually took a 300 level business stats class and understood it very well, well enough to earn a B and be confident in stats. This class, I feel very confused with the materials being presented and I took a stats class already.
Professor was always fair and effective in his grading and ways of teaching.
n/a
Great course overall taught by a great professor. I believe this class could have been made a little more difficult but Professor Karacaovali made every class session count. Maybe he could add more topics into the curriculum as he stated before that this course was a condensed version of a two semester course. I really enjoyed this class and I believe Professor Karacaovali should continue to teach this course.
one of the best professors Ive every had give this guy a raise
TA was okay
good grading system. maybe be more communicative :)
Great class I had a very smooth experience
I hope he teaches other classes too. I try to register his other class next semester, but only thing he will teach is for honored students. He is so great.
n/a
great professor who knows his material but goes fast.
Dr. K and Huixia are very nice and were approachable when I had questions
Keep it up! Doing great! Teaching method is fantastic
The pace of the class was a bit too slow and caused some students to lose interest of subject matter.
Good teacher overall considering how the material in Econ 321 can get a bit dry. I would take another Econ class with him if i have the opportunity to do so.
I really liked the professor and TA. They made themselves very approachable and helped with any questions I had on the course. Lectures were structured nicely so I never was bored; I liked having problems after concepts to help understand how to do the work.
Overall great teacher!! Course was very challenging and stressful but the teacher made taking the class worth it.
Thank You!
I like the use of the iClicker, and I highly appreciate that the textbook is not required.
I love the formula sheets on the exam and quizzes. Really great way to test material, not just looking for memorization, but rather understanding.
Thank you professor Karacaovali! your a 10
I think the attendance policy is absolutely ridiculous! If we are able to understand the material and get it without coming to class we should not get minus points from out overall grade for not being there. We are college students in an upper level course if you cannot be responsible for yourself by now you have some learning to do. I feel like Im in high school all over again. I earned my way to college and I expect to be treated like an adult. The fact that you are forcing us to come to class is ridiculous and honestly a waste of my time. I think if you are going to make attendance points you should just make it however many classes you made out of how many classes total. So if I miss 5 of the 42 classes all semester I would get a 88% for attendance instead of a zero. I went to 88 percent of the classes I think that's worth some credit. Missing 6 classes and getting -1 percent on your grade is dumb. Overall your class is a lecture and you should treat it like it is! You're a college teacher, you shouldn't have to treat us like were 15. I seriously think you need to reconsider attendance policies and maybe even make attendance and participation one category worth 10 percent of your grade and you get points for everyday that you participate in 75% of the questions. That is much more reasonable. The class goes at such a slow pace and 50% of it we should already know! Other than that I think the problem sets and computer assignments are very helpful for reinforcing the concepts!
Very good intro course. Great professor and knows the course material very well. The large class size made the material hard to focus on and lacked participation. Overall, a good course, but could have used more statistics or maybe a group activity to get hands on experience of a study.
Professor Baybars and Quixa (sorry if I spelt your name wrong) made a great team! I really enjoyed the class, and I wouldn't mind just sitting in the class next semester. Great class, my favorite this semester! :D
Take charge of your class. You are the professor in this class, demand the respect that you are due. If you wish to take attendance, take if first thing and do not allow people to just come and go as they please. Also, the mandatory attendance is a bit silly. Again, this is college and if the students WANT to be there, they will be there.
Great class overall.
The TA was never around during class time. She returned graded papers and left. I couldn't even tell you what her name is.
Professor Karacaovali is a great teacher, wish my other econ teachers were like him.

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON362, Fall 2013     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 362 - Trade Policy and Globalization Crn (Section): 75562 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.89 19 0.32 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (11%) 17 (89%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.53 19 0.51 Freq(%) 8 (42%) 9 (47%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.89 19 0.32 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (11%) 17 (89%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.89 19 0.32 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (11%) 17 (89%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 19 0.42 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (21%) 15 (79%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.74 19 0.45 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (26%) 14 (74%)
7. I deepened my interest in the subject matter of this course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.74 19 0.45 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (26%) 14 (74%)
8. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
Being able to get knowledge from notes, videos/lectures in class, and books were all very valuable, as opposed to a course where you are just lectured at constantly. I also liked how we looked at the same issues from multiple viewpoints and it was never apparent what the professors bias was. That helps me know whatever my opinion is it won't be graded unfairly.
The coverage of ethics broadened my insights to different trade and globalization topics
The books and writing assignments were very valuable and informative giving unique perspectives into the topics discussed.
Notes and examples used in class, readings and assignment workload not too great
The background knowledge of the professor helped greatly in his teaching ability.
I liked the simple, easy-to-understand lectures.
Discussion each other and essays closely related to course materials.
International wide-view lectures by the International Doctor
The readings and presentation assignments were most valuable.
I really enjoyed doing the presentation, it gave me a chance to voice myself in class as well as a chance to explore a topic that I was really interested in.
The whole class was great, was nervous about the writing intensive part but that ended up being really interesting and gained a lot of information about trade and globalization!
Discussion of various models of trade, including Heckscher-Ohlin and Ricardian. The ethical perspectives were also useful for examining the tradeoff between productivity and rights. I liked how the outside reading iterated that productivity can also lead to rights--so it's not a direct tradeoff.
Discussing ethics and global issues.
Straight forward and to the point on his expectations from the students.
Every lecture was a learning experience.
9. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
Some lectures got kinda boring, butyou can only spice up so much about trade policy.
I thought that the problem set was not as valuable since there is no test on those topics or information.
More feedback for assignments welcomed
Class was scheduled too late in the day
I feel that we should have had more direction in the presentation. I don't think we covered it in depth in class; the only direction I had was from the sample presentations.
Everything in class was valuable.
Nothing to find at this point...
N/a
None, the assignments were all relevant to class and were doable.
They all seemed valuable. Individual presentations could have been more structured/in depth?
None
Attendance. However, I do understand why it is done so I cannot complain too much about it. It is completely reasonable.
none
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.53 19 0.61 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (5%) 7 (37%) 11 (58%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.89 19 0.32 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (11%) 17 (89%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.95 19 0.23 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (5%) 18 (95%)
13. The writing assignments helped me understand the course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.74 19 0.45 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (26%) 14 (74%)
14. The writing assignments helped me develop abilities to solve problems.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.53 19 0.7 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (11%) 5 (26%) 12 (63%)
15. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 19 0.42 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (21%) 15 (79%)
16. Other comments:
Karacaovali was an excellent professor who has good knowledge in his subject and used relevant supplemental material to further help the class learn and relate to the subject matter
I thought the handouts made class very tedious. I didn't like how the entire powerpoint was distributed with only a few blank spaces. It made it more difficult to be enthusiastic about coming to class.
He is the best professor.
I highly recommend this course to all the students at UH manoa seeking their any professions! The course has been way too beyond my imagination for me to learn useful in my life, and I'm so glad that I got one of the seats in this class.
Fair teacher and class
Definitely recommend this professor! And hopefully I'll get to take another class with him in the future!
Great prof, great class.
Overall a great teacher!

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON362A, Spring 2013     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 362A - Trade Policy and Globalization Crn (Section): 88557 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.5 14 0.76 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 2 (14%) 3 (21%) 9 (64%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.46 14 0.52 Freq(%) 7 (50%) 6 (43%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
5.0 14 0.0 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 14 (100%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
5.0 14 0.0 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 14 (100%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.93 14 0.27 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 13 (93%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.92 14 0.28 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 12 (86%)
7. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
Ethics
Writing and presenting were the most helpful.
The amount of information provided as well as the small class size made for a very good learning environment.
learning about other countries trade regulations and productivity. Also gain a lot of knowledge from the readings he required.
I really enjoyed the discussion of environmental effects of globalization.
The quality of knowledge that Baybars was able to share with us, it was a mix of real world experiences and real life examples.
The presentations were an interactive method of learning that I very much enjoyed. The videos also helped.
Lectures were very informative, and writing assignments definitely helped me organize my thoughts.
The books that was used were very interesting and relevant to the topics discussed in class.
Professor Karacaovali's lectures were always very thorough, informative, and interesting!
Lectures and essays
8. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
Depends on the student presentations
The homework assignment was applicable but because we won't be tested on it I didn't learn much.
Location of the classroom
n/a
Although it this was a writing intensive I felt there was a lot of reading.
The books, while interesting were either too lengthy or too difficult to understand (too much jargon)
Presentations are instructive on an individual level, but not nearly as much on a group level I don't think.
none
9. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.93 14 0.27 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 13 (93%)
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.86 14 0.36 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (14%) 12 (86%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.93 14 0.27 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 13 (93%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
5.0 14 0.0 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 14 (100%)
13. The writing assignments helped me understand the course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.93 14 0.27 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 13 (93%)
14. The writing assignments helped me develop abilities to solve problems.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 14 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (7%) 1 (7%) 12 (86%)
15. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 14 0.43 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (21%) 11 (79%)
16. Other comments:
Excellent course. The professor shows he is dedicated to students learning.
Great Teacher.
Baybars is an excellent teacher, he'll challenge you to think and he'll always encourage you to speak up and give an opinion. Baybars is very personable and he is an easy person to talk to. Hands down I would recommend his class to anyone.
Great professor and a great class! :)
Baybars is a boss.
Very fun class to take for any major. I would defiantly take another class from Professor Baybars.

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON660, Spring 2013     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 660 - International Trade & Welfare Crn (Section): 80759 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
4.0 3 1.73 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (67%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.33 3 1.15 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 0 (0%) 2 (67%)
7. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
The combination of theory and empirical were very useful. This was coupled by directions and suggestions provided by Prof. Karacaovali on futuren notable research endeavors in the field.
Prof.Karacaovali is very patient and nice. I took this class last year. It is notable that he unot only pdated most of the lecture notes in a different format, but put the most popular research in his lectures based on previous experiencs. He also writes down the important equations and conclusions on the board in an interesting way instead of only using PPT.
8. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
None that I can think of.
N/A
9. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
13. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.67 3 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (33%) 2 (67%)
14. Other comments:
A follow-on course (e.g. special topics in international trade) is highly recommended.

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON362, Fall 2012     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 362 - Trade Policy and Globalization Crn (Section): 76094 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.76 21 0.44 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (24%) 16 (76%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.48 21 0.51 Freq(%) 11 (52%) 10 (48%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.9 21 0.3 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (10%) 19 (90%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.71 21 0.46 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 6 (29%) 15 (71%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.76 21 0.44 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (24%) 16 (76%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.86 21 0.36 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (14%) 18 (86%)
7. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
The assignments were relevant and enjoyable
There were a lot of material covered at a very good pace and a lot of opportunities for questioning.
I think all the powerpoint, handouts, and teaching material were extremely valuable and I believe I'll be using it for future courses. The teacher was great in elaborating all topics and I look forward to taking his class again if I could.
the powerpoint slides
The thing I liked the most was how he showed the negative side effects of globalization. I had no idea how bad the conditions are in some of these poor countries. I also liked his choice in media clips that he would show throughout the semester.
I enjoyed the trade policy side of the course although I wish we went into more depth on this topic. I also enjoyed the integration of all the books with the lecture and how closely it followed along in what we were learning. Definitely made writing easier.
Case studies because we saw the application of theories and models. Ethical portion provides a good contrast to the intensiveness of ECON 460. Power points help keep students engaged.
The varied discussions on the books, lectures and videos as well as off hand media. It's a very good stepping stone to Eocn 460 while encourages the students to think critically and in a different non-mechanical matter.
The ability to be creative and apply trade theory to topics of our own interest. (For presentations) Relating Trade theory to world issues today.
I loved the presentations from the class and thought that there was a lot of freedom to discuss whatever topics we felt were valuable. I love the flexibility of the class. Also, I really enjoyed the videos that we watched. I feel like videos make the material easy to understand and they allowed me to understand the magnitude of the trade policies that we were discussing.
The topic of the course is very relevant and interesting
Application of approaches to ethics to different trade policies.
class discussions and presentation
Real-world examples
The presentations done by each student, the videos shown by the instructor and the following discussions, also the lectures with the accompanying handouts with PowerPoint.
videos readings presentations
the way he taught the class and the information i gained
Suggested readings and assignments
8. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
The project was rough because I do not care to speak in front of people
None.
Nothing ;) Everything was great!
none
It was all good!
The presentations made by the students could have been more "strict." The overall topic was appointed, yet students were a bit "lax" in choosing their own topics. In other words, the students' topic could have been a little more related to what the professor set.
Some readings were excessive.
None.
Some students' presentations were not very informative.
I felt that mostly everything about the course was valuable.
Less discussion and class engagement
None.
none
n/a
powerpoint blanks some readings
n/c
9. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.76 21 0.44 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (24%) 16 (76%)
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.81 21 0.4 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (19%) 17 (81%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.71 21 0.64 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (10%) 2 (10%) 17 (81%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.81 21 0.4 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (19%) 17 (81%)
13. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.9 21 0.3 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (10%) 19 (90%)
14. Other comments:
Definitely one of the better, if not best, Economics professor at UHM.
I would love to take any course by Karacavalli again if I could and would highly recommend him to any other student
I like Baybars, he is very personable and easy to approach.
I absolutely loved this course! I am definitely going to recommend this course to other peers whom are economic majors or for those interested in globalization and trade policy.
Internet is bad sometimes, downloading to a hard drive in advance may be more reliable. Some of the longer readings, although not technical, were easy to get lost in because of the length.
I think all four books should be kept in. However, maybe break up the assignments into smaller more frequent ones by breaking it up into smaller reading sections. While I feel it's good experience to feel overwhelmed by a lot of reading material, because the questions are often intended to be open ended, it'd be easier to gradually build up the discussions and types of answers a student can produce. For instance, perhaps break up the readings into halves or so, so there'd be 8 or 12 assignments. While some topics may be incomplete because of this, questions could be catered to molding a type of thinking to incorporate the future possibilities the next readings could bring. Incorporating real life examples into each assignment can help as well-- this can help double check if the student is on the right track or is able to apply the material to current events. Thank you for the wonderful semester!
An understanding and patient instructor and acknowleges the fact that not everyone is an economics major. Encourages growth and accepts diversity from students.
Dr. Karacaovalli integrates relevant examples from outside the field (tv, movies, etc) to help cement concepts and break up the monotony of straight lecturing... He is always available for additional support and is clearly highly knowledgeable about his specialty... Does an excellent job of relating complex concepts and models and making them more accessible...
I would suggest if this class has group discussion besides presentation
None.
professor K is my favorite teacher he's the best :)
Books need to be discussed more in-depth. Great books, but we spent so little time on them.
Great instructor, helped to engage the class in discussions and encouraged and fostered critical thinking skills.

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON460, Fall 2012     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 460 - International Trade & Welfare Crn (Section): 76574 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.77 43 0.53 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 2 (5%) 6 (14%) 35 (81%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.64 43 0.48 Freq(%) 15 (35%) 27 (63%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.77 43 0.43 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 10 (23%) 33 (77%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.77 43 0.43 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 10 (23%) 33 (77%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.65 43 0.57 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (5%) 11 (26%) 30 (70%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.65 43 0.57 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (5%) 11 (26%) 30 (70%)
7. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
Everything done in the course was valuable.
homeworks and quizes
Looking at real world situations
N/A
His lecture is easy to understand.
The lectures.
It was a very consistent pace and there were incentives for a student to master the subjects and go above and beyond.
all of them
Video, PPT, Quizs and Homeworks
Studying international trade models.
The handouts were good. It was good that he prints them out for everyone and has you attend class to fill in the blanks regarding what he is lecturing.
His lecture is so knowledgeable and helpful for me to understand concepts.
Welfare concepts.
Lecture methods which included follow-along handouts with key terms left blank. I found this really helped me to stay involved with the lecture and to add extra notes. Helped me to master the material.
He really encourage students to study and archive their Academic goal through this class
Problem sets and review them very well after graded
The detailed explanations and real life examples given to help us to better understand the concepts presented.
Lecture notes provided good information.
learning about international economies and how the trade.
Problem sets, lectures
learning about trade and welfare
Powerpoints used interactively (filling in certain words on slides)and problem sets helped to aid learning.
everything
Lectures
Professor Karacaovali's explanations of difficult concepts in a way that made it easy for me to understand was very valuable. He knew how to break down the concepts. Also, Professor Karacaovali is very encouraging to his students and personable. He was always available to help.
The comparisons between trade barriers, tariffs, and subsidies. Of course, all other aspects are and have to be presented before these topics in order to understand the diagnostics thereof, therefore making everything exceptionally valuable.
I think the printed lecture notes were really well done. The fact that you still had to go to class to get them, but it wasn't so much where the student is overwhelmed, is something I haven't experienced in a class before this.
Learning about the different policy's of trade and whether it makes countries better or worse off.
Reviews of the problem sets were the most important aspect in learning the material for me. I also liked the handouts instead of textbook approach.
8. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
Nothing was unliked. Everything was interesting and taught me something.
none
N/A
His pronunciation is hard to listen a little bit.
The homeworks.
None.
The two-three week long review session at the beginning of the class.
i think that they where all valuable
None
n/a
The attendance sheet. At the beginning of the semester it was made clear that attendance wasn't apart of the grade. However, almost daily he would pass around an attendance sheet. It has nothing to do with the class but just very cryptic regarding grades.
Nothing.
It seems like this was a very dilute version of the course. A bit of calculus could have been used to consider more interesting trade cases. All the graphs were linear and perhaps not very realistic.
Nothing in particular - a couple instances of un-organization but that was about it (quite minor).
N/A
None
N/A
n/a
None
More opportunities for extra credit since there are only 2 exams.
notes were hard
Nothing
Nothing really. Everything was presented appropriately and in accordance to the topic and course.
n/a
A little bit of the history, but history is always good to know and I'm biased since I don't like history.
The movie Battle in Seattle and the mockumentary about disappearing Mexicans were not really valuable. While they were a good break from continuous lectures, I think news clips of the situations might have been better.
9. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.58 43 0.63 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (7%) 12 (28%) 28 (65%)
10. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.6 43 0.66 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 4 (9%) 9 (21%) 29 (67%)
11. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.6 43 0.58 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (5%) 13 (30%) 28 (65%)
12. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.67 43 0.61 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (7%) 8 (19%) 32 (74%)
13. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 43 0.47 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (2%) 7 (16%) 35 (81%)
14. Other comments:
Was a great professor and was very effective at teaching his students and instructing them.
professor k is my favorite teacher he's the best :)
N/A
THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR TEACHING!
I felt the course was slightly watered down. While I didn't fully ace the first midterm and with the final pending, it's hard for me to say much, but I felt that it could have been much more in-depth. Given the typical department's student, I suppose its OK, but perhaps have optional more difficult problems (original or from the book) available. Other than that, it was a very great class and I learned a lot. Thank you for the great semester!
Excellent teacher, but as stated earlier, the review session at the beginning of the semester should be scaled back a little. At the end of the semester we dropped a section, that could have replaced some of the classes of review.
really liked this class!
I enjoyed this class. I think that the quizzes and homeworks were graded fairly. The only thing I would make more clear is the policy on attendance and how that affects your grade.
I like his class and I want to take his other class again.
Early in the semester we took too long to get through the review material, and it crunched the amount of time we had for the more interesting and challenging content.
Great, fair class. I would definitely take another class with Professor Karacaovali. Sincerely, Troy Thompson
The course was simply too simple and slow-paced for a 400 level class. I would have liked the class much better if the the lectures had been less redundant and if we had spent less time on simple concepts like consumer/producer surplus.
Dr. Karacaovalli integrates relevant examples from outside the field (tv, movies, etc) to help cement concepts and break up the monotony of straight lecturing... He is always available for additional support and is clearly highly knowledgeable about his specialty... Does an excellent job of relating complex concepts and models and making them more accessible...
I've learned about trade and welfare very well from handouts and problem sets. I am willing to take more Econ classes from Mr. Karacaovali! Best Econ instructor ever!!
Great professor. Would take another class.
n/a
Excellent professor. Very knowledgeable and moves at a pace that is suitable for students.
great teacher!
he is very clear
Good teacher and knowledgeable about trade economics
Amazing individual and thorough with his teachings. Very generous, and very knowledgeable. Would recommend to take him!
I would love to take more classes from Professor Karacaovali!
I would not hesitate to take another class from him again.
Good professor who knows his material and who knows when students might need a break from lecture.

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON321, Spring 2012     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 321 - Introduction to Statistics Crn (Section): 86745 (002)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.13 31 1.26 Freq(%) 3 (10%) 7 (23%) 8 (26%) 11 (35%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.9 31 0.3 Freq(%) 3 (10%) 28 (90%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.75 32 0.57 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 4 (13%) 26 (81%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.56 32 0.62 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 10 (31%) 20 (63%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.25 32 0.95 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 5 (16%) 8 (25%) 17 (53%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.31 32 0.74 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (16%) 12 (38%) 15 (47%)
7. I deepened my interest in the subject matter of this course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
3.94 32 1.05 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 3 (9%) 9 (28%) 7 (22%) 13 (41%)
8. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
His explanations were very good.
Probability and Standard Deviation
i especialy liked the confidence intervals of normal distrobution.
The hand-outs gave me a good idea of what was expected and also provided useful information.
Probability.
Class lecture notes
As a biology major learning how to use Excel will be vital in my future career. Prior to this course, Excel was extremely difficult for me to use. Professor Karacaovali demonstrated how to use Excel in a simple, but effective manner.
Being able to determine percentages for the numerous different problems we were given.
applying all the equations to real situations.
Depends on major
Just statistics in general
I think that finding probabilities would be helpful for the future.
study in groups
The lecture handouts for every chapter were incredibly helpful. They laid out everything we needed to know without the often bulky wording of textbooks.
The applied statistics. Mostly Probability.
The homework assignments helped me understand the material more. Thanks for explaining them.
The pace of the class was great. It gave me time to review the materials and understand them better.
Although math is not my strong point. I learned a lot from each chapter.
I really appreciated the handouts. It was easier for me to see the material condensed into the important information that we needed to know. I also like that fact that we worked together on problems in class as a group. We had helped each other to understand concepts that we couldn't quite get.
Examples used and handouts given. The formula sheets also really helped during the exam.
The problem sets and the lecture handouts really helped.
He went over all the assignments to make sure everyone understand the concepts and the problems.
Understanding and configuring digits and word problems that the common population uses on a daily basis, whether it is towards firms or government evaluations in regards of profit or economies.
how the very basics were covered before going into the harder stuff
9. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
N/A
alot of the jargon and renaming of simple concepts
Not too many students showed up to class.
N/A
Computer assignments
There have been no aspects of this course that have not been valuable to my student career.
The beginning of the course started off a bit slow. A lot more content could've been easily covered in the amount of time.
depends on major
not much
lectures
everything else
All were valuable.
There really wasn't anything that I din't like about the course. It did move a little fast for me, but I was still able to keep up
The computer assignments felt useless.
N/A
Honestly, all of them are valuable when looked at from a third person point of view, because statistics is something that happens and evaluated in our everyday life. So, it is important to at least have a common knowledge of the subject.
computer assignments
10. The instructor appears to have a thorough knowledge of the subject.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.81 32 0.47 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (3%) 4 (13%) 27 (84%)
11. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.31 32 0.82 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (3%) 4 (13%) 11 (34%) 16 (50%)
12. The instructor is friendly.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.71 31 0.59 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 5 (16%) 24 (77%)
13. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.53 32 0.67 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (9%) 9 (28%) 20 (63%)
14. The instructor treated students with respect.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.75 32 0.51 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (3%) 6 (19%) 25 (78%)
15. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.53 32 0.76 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (16%) 5 (16%) 22 (69%)
16. What two or three single words best describe this instructor?
Thorough. Easy to understand
Genuine, Helpful, Kind
he is a very aprochable proffesor and is very willing to help outside of class. seems like a cool guy to grab a drink with
Helpful and understanding.
Enthusiastic and knowledgeable
Smart, fast
Professor Karacaovali is helpful to students with questions, knowledgeable in the field of statistics, and makes learning statistics interesting.
organized, prepared, available
Motivated, enthusiastic
turkish teacher today
Smart, Nice, Awesome
He was very helpful. Always encourage students. He knew course content very well.
chill consistent
Friendly, accommodating, likable
freindly, foreign, distracted
competent, professional
Nice, smart, friendly
Caring, Smart, On time
informative and helpful
Friendly, enthusiastic, intelligent
Friendly, understanding.
Fair, well organized,
Generous, Smart, and Kind
Calm Friendly Knowledgeable
17. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.44 32 0.62 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (6%) 14 (44%) 16 (50%)
18. The TA gives clear and understandable explanations.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.48 32 1.24 Freq(%) 2 (6%) 5 (16%) 6 (19%) 9 (28%) 7 (22%) 3 (9%)
19. The TA appears to have a thorough knowledge of the subject.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.83 32 1.1 Freq(%) 1 (3%) 2 (6%) 8 (25%) 8 (25%) 10 (31%) 3 (9%)
20. The TA grades paper (exams, homework) fairly.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
4.0 32 1.0 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 3 (9%) 5 (16%) 10 (31%) 11 (34%) 3 (9%)
21. The TA was easy to talk with and available for consultation.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.72 30 1.21 Freq(%) 1 (3%) 4 (13%) 4 (13%) 8 (27%) 8 (27%) 5 (17%)
22. The TA's oral speaking was clear and effective.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree   N/A  
3.62 31 1.05 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 4 (13%) 11 (35%) 6 (19%) 8 (26%) 2 (6%)
23. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.5 32 0.76 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (16%) 6 (19%) 21 (66%)
24. Other comments:
It would be a good idea to have students do even more group work and daily presenting
I'm glad I took this class with Professor Karacaovali. I learned a lot and it was a great experience.
I think you should make attendance mandatory if you want more people to come
It was a very pleasant environmented class.
ta wasnt there hardly
Good job.
Regarding what as spoken about in class recently, on of my previous professors ha password protected the lectures and notes he put on laulima and only gave the passwords to those who attended class regularly.
He was an excellent professor!
I honestly am not a fan of statistics, but I understand the reasoning of why it valuable to the degree requirement. But, if this means anything, I am taking him again, and would like to as many times possible, or as required :)

Baybars Karacaovali: ECON460, Fall 2011     Back to top

Campus: University of Hawaii at Manoa Department: Economics
Course: ECON 460 - International Trade & Welfare Crn (Section): 77343 (001)    
1. Class Level (pick one) - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Freshman   Sophomore   Junior   Senior   Grad   Other  
3.89 28 0.31 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (11%) 25 (89%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%)
2. Course - please note that by answering this question you could potentially jeopardize your anonymity
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Elective   Required  
1.7 27 0.47 Freq(%) 8 (30%) 19 (70%)
3. The instructor demonstrated knowledge of course content.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.82 28 0.39 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 5 (18%) 23 (82%)
4. The instructor fulfilled the goals of the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.68 28 0.55 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 7 (25%) 20 (71%)
5. The instructor communicated effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.39 28 0.83 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 2 (7%) 0 (0%) 11 (39%) 15 (54%)
6. I gained a good understanding of concepts/principles in this field.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.54 28 0.79 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 2 (7%) 6 (21%) 19 (68%)
7. I deepened my interest in the subject matter of this course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.36 28 0.83 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 3 (11%) 9 (32%) 15 (54%)
8. I felt that this course challenged me intellectually.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.32 28 0.67 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (11%) 13 (46%) 12 (43%)
9. Which aspects of the course were most valuable?
Chapters on tariffs and barriers were valuable especially considering APEC was held during this semester. Connecting the models with current real events helps a lot. Reading assignments helped.
Learning about trade aspects between countries, the power point slides
The lectures were useful and easy to understand.
power points explanation
All models covered Thank you Baybars!!!
I enjoyed learning about contemporary issues in trade
reading assignments
Understanding the ins and outs of trade between two countries and how it affects the world market.
Professor Baybars was very thorough in his lectures and went a pace that everyone could follow.
This class was thorough on all its theories. I like how the course ramped up in difficulty.
Probably my favorite class this semester due to the practical application of subject matter.
Clear examples and what was covered in class was put in exams
The graphs were very helpful in illustrating before and after effects of things such as tariffs, tax, etc. The practice midterms covered a majority of the topics aforementioned and familiarized me with the exam format, such that I was comfortable taking it. The student presentations brought new material, topics, and ideas without being too distracting. It shone light into other areas of economics in which we may be able to apply what we learned in Econ 460.
When Professor Karacaovali would explain further why the models were a certain way. It was helpful for our own sense, so we could understand more than just the surface of the material. I wish it were possible to do more problem sets. Possibly at least two problem sets per topic? If it were possible it would be helpful to have an on-line program to do the homework, so we could get immediate feedback, and do more practice problems. The midterm review sheet and the problem sets were very valuable and helpful though.
The effects of international trade in the world economy and how it relates to current day politics as well as trade policies that have been passed or are about to be passed.
Learning the basics of Economics once again, i believe was very important. Many times i do forget terminology, so it was nice to revisit Ricardian model.
example problems and lotsa of extra resources
Materials are pretty good. Easy to understand even if you are no native students.
The reading assignments and the problem sets as well as the practice exams greatly helped in preparing for the exams.
The lectures, course content and class materials.
Baybars is very clear in his explanations of the various topics presented in class. He doesn't assume that his students should already know the subject matter from reading the book.
10. Which aspects of the course were least valuable?
None.
This is hard, but I wish we had covered more material. I understand that not all of the class is on the same level, but it was a little slow for me.
book
NONE Thank you Baybars!!!
Did not enjoy the extensive math and technical application of theory
problem sets were too hard i wasnt prepared well enough for them
N/A
The reading assignments weren't terrible but seemed a bit unnecessary. I would have like to see more real life examples brought up during class whether its through a video or a article.
Class general interest
The reading assignments were a toss up between good and bad. Good because they related to the topics we covered in class and introduced real life situations in which we could apply what we learned in Econ 460. Bad because they were not included in exams. It would be nice to see some questions related to the reading assignments on the exam so we are constantly reminded that we need to apply what we learned into the real world. Also, including some questions from the readings on the exam would make students take the reading assignments more seriously...
nothing
all were beneficial to the application of the subject
some lengthy lectures
Nothing
None.
Probably the reading assignments. I don't feel like I gained much from doing those assignments.
11. The instructor appears to have a thorough knowledge of the subject.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 28 0.42 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 6 (21%) 22 (79%)
12. The instructor is sensitive to student difficulty with course work.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.5 28 0.75 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 9 (32%) 17 (61%)
13. The instructor was able to explain concepts clearly and effectively.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.46 28 0.74 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 1 (4%) 10 (36%) 16 (57%)
14. The instructor is friendly.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.68 28 0.55 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 7 (25%) 20 (71%)
15. The instructor acknowledges all questions insofar as possible.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.68 28 0.55 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 7 (25%) 20 (71%)
16. The instructor is willing to meet and help students outside class.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.54 28 0.69 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 3 (11%) 7 (25%) 18 (64%)
17. The instructor treated students with respect.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.79 28 0.42 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 6 (21%) 22 (79%)
18. The instructor makes me feel free to ask questions.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.64 28 0.62 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (7%) 6 (21%) 20 (71%)
19. The instructor was willing to help.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.71 28 0.53 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 6 (21%) 21 (75%)
20. The instructor was well organized and prepared for each session.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.7 27 0.54 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 6 (22%) 20 (74%)
21. What two or three single words best describe this instructor?
Helpful, thorough, eager.
professional
SMART
Understanding Patient
Understanding, passionate, caring
nice knowledgable
Hardworking, enthusiastic
Thorough, approachable, and fair
Intelligent, careful, understanding
prepared, helpful, encouraging
Helpful, knowledgeable, compasionate
Wastes no time
Thorough. Conscientious.
knowledgable, approachable, easy-going
Organized, Intelligent, and willing to help
organized, thorough, considerate
Kind
Helpful, cheerful, encouraging
Baybars was motivated, committed, and dedicated to provide a quality course for his students; he cares about his students learning the material.
Knowledgeable, intelligent, organized
interactive
22. Global appraisal: Considering everything how would you rate this INSTRUCTOR?
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Very Poor   Poor   Average   Good   Excellent  
4.46 28 0.64 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 2 (7%) 11 (39%) 15 (54%)
23. Assignments are returned promptly.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.63 27 0.56 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 8 (30%) 18 (67%)
24. The course materials (texts, handouts) make a valuable contribution to the course.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.54 28 0.79 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 2 (7%) 6 (21%) 19 (68%)
25. The instructor was fair in grading and criteria of grades.
Mean N-Size Std Dev   Strongly Disagree   Disagree   Neutral   Agree   Strongly Agree  
4.75 28 0.52 Freq(%) 0 (0%) 0 (0%) 1 (4%) 5 (18%) 22 (79%)
26. Other comments:
Very fair professors, punctual and eager to teach. It is really encouraging as a student to have a professor that cares. Makes you feel comfortable to ask questions and participate. Lectures can get a bit dry sometimes but lack of student interest does that to you. Constantly relating models to real examples would help connect the material. Material is understandable and examples are too but being able to compare the bigger picture is helpful for visualization.
good teacher, great knowledge
Most of the students were not at a high enough level to begin to understand the material which prevented some students from enjoying the class. It was fun. It was easy. I sympathize with the professor because he wanted us to learn and appreciate the material but students enrolled in the course just for a passing grade which is a real shame, but I did sincerely enjoy ALL material covered and was a bit disappointed that other students didn't care, I look forward to your other classes here at UH.
i wasnt well enough informed on due dates for assignments so i ended up not being able to turn in assignments that i wanted to. extra credit presentation i also had no knowledge of how was supposed to do it wether sign up for a day or if we were assigned a day i cant find sign up sheet anywhere also i think my midterm was graded far too harshly and his office hours are always when i have class
Prof. Karacaovali is very enthusiastic in teaching, although the material is challenging his demeanor never falters and always comes to class with a smile.
The class was great. The reading assignments were a great complement to the topics covered. The student presentations were also a good change up. Trade theory is fairly bland, but the class seemed to go by pretty fast for what it was. He asks some questions that are too easy, so most people don't like to answer those.
Powerpoints very very helpful. Always wanted class participation but really shouldn't take it personally if no one wants to speak up. Class presentations and reading assignments were a good way of helping us broaden our view of the subject.
Lectures sometimes felt like they were draggong on and on, but maybe this is because we only meet two days a week so the material has to be "crammed" Idk, but having to jot down notes from the beginning to the end of class hurts my brain. Maybe we could have breaks or something...or you can switch to just verbal teaching or switching to powerpoint.
Professor Karacaovali is a great professor and addition to UH Manoa. Very happy to have taken a course from him.
Baybars is a very good professor that comes to class prepared and on time. He is very knowledgable about international trade and welfare and is able to teach it in a clear way. He is always willing to help a student with any questions. I think the class would benefit if he slowed down when writing notes on the board. Overall, I would recommend other Econ majors to take his classes and believe he is a valuable asset to the Econ department
This class, i must admit was a little challenging for me. I believe Baybars should write more legibly on the board, and notes would be more understandable. Otherwise the course became more and more interesting. Im glad i took this course, it really is something we should all learn since we go through trade and globalization everyday. Dont worry Professor, even though our class doesnt speak much we still appreciate your teaching methods. Most of the econ classes I have taken have been like this. I found that after your first evaluation, you were able to make the class participate more. Thanks professor for an interesting semester.
Baybars is an excellent professor. UH Economics Department needs to find more Baybars to teach at our Economics Department. Perhaps UH can develop an International Economics curriculum for students to graduate, just like at other prestigious schools.
I would take a class from this instructor again
This class gives all the relevant information without too much extra too confuse us. I think the size of the classroom was too large which makes it feel more like a lecture. If the classroom size was smaller, I think it would make the class more interactive but the professor does well in trying to engage the class in discussion.