Teacher Resources
Oral Communication Focus
You are at this web site because you are interested in teaching an Oral
Communication Focus (O) class or you already are teaching an O class and would
like more ideas about assignments, giving feedback to students, etc.
We'd like to thank the Department of Speech,
University of Hawai'i at Manoa for the information at this site.
Here's an index of what follows on this page.
-
Requirements
for a class to be designated as "Oral Communication" ("O")
-
Rationale for
an oral communication
requirement
-
Oral communication defined
-
Types of acceptable
assignments
-
Issues to consider when designing O assignments
-
Steps to
effective oral communication--typical steps students should follow when
preparing to give an oral presentation
-
Communication apprehension
-
Helping students manage communication apprehension
-
Evaluating
student presentations
-
References/Bibliography
1. Requirements for a class to be designated as "Oral Communication" ("O")
If you propose your course for the O designation, the
Oral
Communication Focus Board will review your proposal/course description to see if it
meets these 5 Hallmarks:
HALLMARK 1. Each student will conduct or participate in a minimum of three oral
communication assignments or a comparable amount of oral communication
activity during the class. In addition, at least 40% of the final grade for
a 3-credit course will be a function of the student’s oral
communication activities (30% for a 4-credit course; 60% for a
2-credit course; 100% for a 1-credit course). HALLMARK 2. Each student will receive explicit training, in the context of the class,
in oral communication concerns relevant to the assignment or activity.
HALLMARK 3. Each student will receive specific feedback, critiquing, and grading of
the oral communication assignments or activities from the instructor.
HALLMARK 4. If instructor feedback primarily involves individual or paired students,
enrollment will be limited to 20 students. If instructor feedback primarily involves
groups of students, enrollment will be limited to 30.
HALLMARK 5. The class will be numbered
at the 300- or 400-level.
Instructors who are willing to meet these
Hallmarks in their class are encouraged to submit a proposal to have their
class designated as an "O" class.
2. Rationale for Oral Communication Focus requirement
The National Communication Association has established basic oral
communication competencies for college graduates. These competencies were culled
from numerous articles published in top tier journals in the Speech
Communication field. Among the competencies set forth by the National
Communication Association are basic skills for informing, persuading, and
relating to others. These skills include sending and receiving oral
communication messages, message development and organization, adapting messages
to the particular situation and audience, communicating interpersonally and in
small groups, and evaluating the oral communication messages of others. (See
National
Communication Association web site for further information.)
Oral communication skills benefit students academically, interpersonally, and
in their future careers. Students who participate in class discussions are more
involved in their own learning. Students who can express themselves well find it
easier to give oral presentations in class as well as to interact with their
instructors and with other students. Employers seek applicants who have
excellent oral communication skills.
Because UHM believes that its students should be prepared to use oral communication
skills in a variety of contexts, including public
presentations and group and interpersonal interactions, an O course is required
for graduation.
3. Oral communication defined
Oral communication involves expressing and sharing ideas and information as
well as influencing others through verbal and nonverbal symbols. Instructors who
want to improve students' oral communication skills can design assignments that ask
students to
- inform - provide others with new information,
- persuade - modify or change attitudes and/or behaviors, or to
reinforce already-existing attitudes or behaviors, or
- entertain or move - influence others' emotions.
4. Acceptable class assignments
Instructors of O Focus courses can use a variety of assignments to meet
Hallmark 1 which states that students in O courses will "conduct or participate in a minimum of three oral
communication assignments or a comparable amount of oral communication
activity during the course. . . ."
Here are examples of acceptable class assignments:
-
Informative presentations or speeches, whether formal or informal
-
Persuasive or influence appeals (e.g., sales presentations, motivational
presentations, appeals for policy changes)
-
Chapter or section presentations to the class (e.g., presenting course
content, presenting journal articles)
-
Group presentations (e.g., presenting results of a group project to class)
-
Panel discussions (e.g., several students speaking with one another on a
topic in front of an audience of peers)
-
Debates (individual or team)
-
Interviews (e.g., mock job interviews, research interviews,
interrogations)
-
Facilitation and participation in class discussions, group discussions,
community gatherings
-
Participation in outreach or service learning activities (e.g., tutoring,
teaching, coaching, presentations)
-
Press conferences
-
Creative or aesthetic performances (e.g., storytelling, performance of
literature, oral interpretations or readings)
-
Oral critiques of others’ performances or presentations
5. Issues for faculty members to consider when designing O assignments
Answering these five questions will help you
effectively design O assignments. You can then translate your answers into
assignment guideline sheets or into parts of your syllabus so that students will
understand the purpose of the assignment and how they can succeed.
1. What is the purpose of the assignment? What are you
trying to accomplish?
Examples
-
Help students learn the course content
-
Have students find and present supplementary course
materials (to the class or a small group)
-
Improve students' communication skills
-
Give students opportunities to practice professional
skills (e.g., interviewing, presenting at business meetings or academic
conferences, performing for an audience)
-
Add variety to class sessions
-
Evaluate students' mastery of course content
2. How will my students, the physical environment,
available technology, etc., affect the assignment?
Consider these items:
-
Students' prior experience with oral assignments;
students' class standing
-
Small room vs. large room; moveable chairs vs.
stationary chairs
-
Available technology (PowerPoint, television, VCR,
video camera, overhead projector)
3. What do my students need to know to succeed?
Consider adding a statement or two about each of these
items:
-
Purpose of the presentation (inform, persuade,
entertain)
-
Assigned or choice of topic?
-
Types of topics that are allowed (if choice is given)
-
Speaking time; date of presentation
-
Individual or group presentation?
-
Question/answer section (discussion session) included?
-
Visual aid requirements
-
Materials required in addition to the oral presentation
(notes, outline, paper, citations) and their format (e.g., typed, APA style guide)
-
Peer review of classmates' presentations
-
Videotaping of presentation
-
Grading criteria (see #4 below)
4. How will you give students feedback and grade/evaluate
the presentations? [The O Focus Board will look to see how you meet Hallmark 3
in your proposal, "Each student will receive specific feedback, critiquing, and grading of
the oral communication assignments or activities."]
Consider these:
-
Percentage of course grade [The
Focus Board will also look at how you meet Hallmark 1: " ...at least 40% of the final course
grade will be a function of the student’s oral communication
activities."]
-
Letter grade; credit/no credit; +/-; etc.
-
Evaluators (self-evaluation; peer evaluation;
instructor evaluation; non-class audience members)
-
Grading criteria
-
features evaluated (content, delivery, additional
materials such as an outline, etc.)
-
forms or checklists for self-evaluation, peer,
instructor, audience
-
Format of feedback
5. How will you help students prepare? [When the O Focus Board
reviews an O proposal, it will look for how Hallmark 2 is satisfied: Each student will receive explicit training, in the context of the class,
in oral communication concerns relevant to the assignment or activity.]
Examples
-
Student-teacher conferences
-
Handouts, guidebooks
-
Demonstrations of oral communication techniques
-
Guidance in choosing and developing a topic, help with drafting
the presentation, etc.
-
Class time for peer discussion and peer assistance
6. Steps to effective oral communication: Typical steps students should follow when preparing to give an oral
presentation
Below are 9 steps that students can follow so that their oral communication
presentation is successful.
Step 1. Determine general purpose
First, either assign or have students decide on the general purpose of their oral presentation:
to inform, to persuade, or to entertain or move an audience.
Oral Communication Foundations & Impromptu Speaking
(PowerPoint presentation)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Then, you can help your students by pointing out that effective oral
communicators are concerned with three elements: (1)
content; (2) organization and (3) delivery of messages.
is the actual information that is conveyed in an oral
presentation.
Organization is how the presentation is structured, including the
organizational pattern as well as the inclusion of an introduction, body, and
conclusion to the message.
Delivery includes the verbal and nonverbal means by which the message is
conveyed to the audience.
Step 2. Analyze the audience
Communicators often say things they regret or that are not well-received by
audiences simply because the communicator failed to properly analyze his or
her audience before speaking. Students must analyze their audience in order to
tailor their message to that audience.
Speakers analyze their audience prior to a presentation so she/he can
determine the knowledge level of an audience as well as factors such as likes
and dislikes, attitudes, values, and so on. Speakers should also analyze
demographic characteristics of an audience such as sex, age, ethnicity,
religion, political affiliations, and so on. In short, a speaker should gather
as much information as possible prior to giving a presentation, so that she or
he presents the most useful, relevant information possible and avoids
offending or embarrassing audience members during the presentation.
A speaker analyzes an audience by making observations of audience members
prior to the presentation, or by having audience members complete a
questionnaire that includes demographic and attitudinal information.
Information about audience members in a particular organization can be
provided by a contact person in the organization or from the organization’s
Web site.
Audience Analysis (PowerPoint presentation, 5
slides)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 3. Determine the specific purpose
While a general purpose is to inform, to persuade, or to entertain or move
an audience, a specific purpose indicates the thesis, or the specific content,
of a presentation. For example, you may ask your students to give an
informative presentation on the work of an eminent architect. The general
purpose is to inform, and the specific purpose might be to provide the
audience with information about the work of Frank Lloyd Wright. The specific
purpose narrows the topic and focuses the presentation. The specific purpose
should be stated in the presentation so the audience knows exactly what to
expect.
Informative Speaking (PowerPoint
presentation)
Persuasive Speaking (PowerPoint presentation)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 4. Research the presentation
Students should gather facts, figures, examples, testimony, and so on to
present to their audience. This information is gathered, for example, from
library sources, the Internet, interviews, periodicals.
Establishing Your Credibility &
Presenting Evidence (PowerPoint presentation, 10 slides)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 5. Organize and outline the presentation
After gathering information regarding the topic of the presentation,
students should organize the information. This requires determining an
appropriate organizational pattern and dividing the information into major
points.
Presentations can be organized chronologically, topically, spatially (how
things relate to one another by location or position), or by cause-effect or
problem-solution patterns. Typically, presentations contain two to five major
points.
It is helpful to have students prepare written outlines of their
presentations, including an introduction, a body, and a conclusion.
The introduction of a presentation outline usually includes some type of
device to gain the attention of the audience, such as a story, an anecdote, a
quotation, or a question for the audience to think about or to answer aloud.
Also in the introduction is the thesis or specific purpose statement, which is
typically a single declarative sentence. Finally, it is helpful to include a
sentence which previews each of the major points to be included in the body of
the presentation.
The body of the presentation outline includes the major points and
sub-points or details to be covered in the presentation.
The conclusion of the presentation outline includes a summary of the major
points covered and a statement that concludes the presentation smoothly.
Preparation of a concluding statement helps students avoid an awkward ending
to the presentation.
Sample: Oral Presentation Outline Format for
Students
Organizing (PowerPoint presentation)
Outlining (PowerPoint presentation)
Introductions & Conclusions (PowerPoint
presentation)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 6. Prepare visual aids
It is useful to have visual representations of material in a presentation.
Visual aids make a presentation more clear, interesting, and memorable. Visual
aids help a speaker capture the attention of the audience and also make the
presentation more understandable to the audience.
Types of visual aids that students may use include PowerPoint, overhead
transparencies, videotapes or DVDs, objects, models, drawings, people, slides,
maps, photographs and charts or graphs.
Since the purpose of using visual aids is to enhance a presentation by
providing a visual representation, it is important that students follow some
basic rules in using visual aids:
Visual aids should add to the
presentation
Visual aids should be easily seen by the audience . Words, charts,
photos, and so on need to be large enough so that everyone in the room can see
them. Visual aids that are too small to see do not add to a presentation;
indeed, they compromise the credibility of the speaker.
Speakers should not obstruct the audience’s view of the visual aids .
If a speaker displays visual aids on a screen in front of the room, he/she
should not stand in front of the screen.
Maintain eye contact while using the visual aids. In other words, talk
to the audience, not to the visual aid.
Explain the visual aids . A speaker cannot assume that the audience
will understand the visual aids; interpret and explain the visual aids.
Do not pass objects among the audience . Speakers sometimes do this so
that audience members can get a closer look at the object. However, if the
object was too small, the speaker should not have used it. Passing objects
among the audience is distracting. It would be better for the speaker to
invite audience members to look at the objects after the presentation, or
after class.
Use handouts appropriately. Unless a speaker will refer to a handout
throughout the presentation, it is best to wait until after the presentation
to distribute handouts. Audience members can become distracted by reading the
handout rather than listening to the speaker.
Use appropriate visual aids . Dangerous or illegal visual aids should
be avoided.
Practice the presentation with the visual aids. Students should
prepare visual aids well enough in advance so they can practice their
presentation with them. This will give the students a good indication of how
long it will take to display and discuss the visual aids during the actual
presentation in class.
Learn how to use the equipment in the classroom . It is helpful to
emphasize to students the importance of planning visual aids in advance and
making sure they know how to use any electronic or computer equipment ahead of
time.
Many classrooms at UHM contain computers and other electronic equipment,
and include instructions for using the equipment. To determine what equipment
your classroom has, see the UHM Center for Instructional Support Web site:
www.cis.hawaii.edu
Visual Aids (PowerPoint
presentation)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 7. Rehearse the presentation
It is helpful for students to rehearse their presentations many times
before delivering the presentation to the class. The best way to do so is for
students to practice the presentation from beginning to end (from introduction
to concluding statement), following their outline and incorporating their
visual aids.
If you have given students a time limit for the presentation (e.g. 10-12
minutes), encourage them to time their presentation when they practice.
Students often think that five minutes is a very long time to speak in front
of the class, and are quite surprised to learn that their presentation was
actually 15 minutes long!
Delivery & Nonverbal Cues (PowerPoint
presentation, 7 slides)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Step 8. Deliver the presentation to the class
Finally, students are ready to give their presentations to the class. There
are various modes of delivery, and it is helpful to direct students to use the
most appropriate mode for the situation.
A manuscript mode of delivery involves writing a presentation
word-for-word and reading the presentation to the audience. It is used when a
speaker needs to be very precise in what she/he says. For example, the
President of the United States primarily uses a manuscript mode so as not to
say something inappropriate or inaccurate.
A memorized mode of delivery involves writing a presentation
word-for-word and reciting the presentation from memory. It is used for
shorter presentations, such as introducing a speaker or delivering a toast or
a eulogy.
An impromptu mode of delivery involves very little or no preparation
or practice time. It is used for "on-the-spot" presentations such as
participating in class, giving directions to someone on the street, or for
presenting results of in-class activities.
An extemporaneous mode of delivery involves thorough preparation and
practice and is conversational in style. It is used for most types of in-class
presentations because it allows students to use notes while they speak and
allows for flexibility during a presentation. For example, if a student is
presenting from a manuscript, he/she cannot adapt to audience feedback by
deviating from their script. With extemporaneous delivery, students can adjust
the complexity or the length of their message to fit the situation at hand.
Perhaps the best argument for an extemporaneous mode of delivery is that it is
conversational and therefore more interesting for the audience to listen to.
It is important to look at various aspects of delivery when evaluating a
speaker: Gestures and movement, vocal variety, eye contact, and use of visual
aids.
Gestures and movement. Speakers should be encouraged to move about the
room as they speak, rather than standing behind a podium or lectern for the
entire presentation. This movement makes the presentation more interesting to
listen to, creates a more immediate environment in which the physical and
psychological distance between the speaker and the audience is lessened, and
also helps a speaker channel their nervous energy. A moderate amount of
movement is best; more movement than simply standing in one place but not so
much movement that it seems the speaker is pacing during the entire
presentation. Gestures should not be planned but rather should occur naturally
as a speaker delivers her/his presentation.
Vocal variety: Vocal variety includes tone of voice, the rate at which
we speak, pitch, volume, proper pronunciation, articulation, and the use of
pauses. Effective vocal variety is crucial to effective delivery. We are all
familiar with speakers who talk so fast that their words become jumbled, or
those who talk so slow and monotone that they put us to sleep.
Speakers should avoid using filled pauses such as "um,"
"uh," "like," and "you know." Speakers often
vocalize pauses because they are uncomfortable with even a second of silence
while standing before an audience. Emphasize to students that unfilled pauses
are perfectly acceptable and can be used to emphasize important points in a
presentation (e.g. the dramatic pause).
Eye contact and facial expression. Eye contact with an audience makes a
speaker seem more believable and trustworthy and it also helps speakers gauge
audience feedback. Speakers can use facial expressions to convey their
feelings, attitudes and emotions. Appropriate facial expressions make a
speaker more interesting to listen to and enhance a speaker’s credibility.
Step 9. Self assess the presentation
In our public speaking courses, student presentations are videotaped and
the students watch the tape and write a self-evaluation of their performance.
Even if videotaping is not possible, it is useful to have students reflect in
some way on their presentation - the strengths of the presentation as well as
things to work on for the next presentation.
Sample: Self Evaluation Form for Students
7. Communication apprehension
Many students suffer communication apprehension (CA) -- "a fear or anxiety associated with
communicating" (Richmond & McCroskey, 1998). CA is quite common,
especially when it comes to public speaking. Highly apprehensive students are
hesitant to take courses where oral communication is a component, and do so only
if they need to fulfill certain requirements for their major and/or graduation.
CA is experienced not only in public speaking, but in any oral communication
situation such as interpersonal communication, meetings, small group
communication, talking on the phone, employment interviews, and so on. CA is
experienced differently by everyone. Some people are not apprehensive about
communicating regardless of the situation.
Students can assess their level of apprehension in different settings by
completing the Personal Report of Communication Apprehension (PRCA-24) (McCroskey,
1982).
Personal Report of Communication Apprehension - web
format
Personal Report of Communication Apprehension -
Acrobat (PDF) format for easy printing
8. Helping students manage communication apprehension
Here are a few tips for highly apprehensive students to help them deal with their fear of
oral communication:
-
Prepare thoroughly. Outline the presentation and practice it several times
before delivering the presentation to an audience.
-
Speak about a familiar topic. It is much easier to speak on topics that we
already know about, rather than trying to tackle unfamiliar territory. Students
sometimes choose topics because they know they can find a great deal of
information on that topic. However, it is best to stick with topics that
interest you and that are familiar.
-
Realize that you are not alone. Most people are apprehensive about speaking
in public and just as nervous as everyone else about giving a class
presentation.
-
Focus on getting the message across to the audience rather than on what the
audience is thinking of you as a speaker. Realize that you feel more nervous
than you actually look. The audience is focused on listening to your message,
not on how nervous you look.
-
Use positive visualization. It is helpful to imagine yourself giving a
successful presentation to an appreciative audience. Negative thoughts and
doubts increase anxiety, whereas positive visualization makes you feel more
comfortable and confident.
-
Practice relaxation techniques. It is helpful to manage speaking anxiety by
using techniques such as deep-breathing, exercise, meditation, or yoga. Students
may want to take a walk across campus before a presentation, for example.
-
Use visual aids in your presentation. Students report that using visual aids
is helpful in managing anxiety. This is because the attention is diverted from
the speaker to the visual aids and also because visual aids give the speaker
something to work with while they speak. This gives the speaker something to do
with their hands and helps to channel nervous energy.
-
Practice. The more a speaker practices, the more familiar he/she is with the
information and the more comfortable he/she will be during the actual
presentation. The value of practice cannot be emphasized enough when it comes to
giving class presentations.
9. Evaluating student presentations: Written feedback from the teacher
Perhaps the best way to provide written feedback of students’ oral
presentations is to use an evaluation form with pre-set categories as well as
room for open-ended comments. The sample formats presented here offer checklists
for content, organization, and delivery.
Written comments from the instructor may include perceived limitations of the
presentation (e.g. "I didn’t hear a thesis statement") and positive
feedback (e.g. "Presentation was very well organized").
It is helpful to provide specific feedback so that students know what to work
on for their next presentation (e.g. "Work on eye contact so that you are
looking to all areas of the room, rather than just to your right side").
Because public speaking is very difficult for many people, it is especially
important to emphasize the positive aspects of the presentation as well as areas
for improvement when evaluating student presentations.
Sample: Informative Evaluation Form
- web page format Sample:
Informative Evaluation Form - Acrobat (PDF) for easy
printing
Sample: Persuasive Evaluation Form
- web page format Sample:
Persuasive Evaluation Form
- Acrobat (PDF) for easy printing)
If you'd like to create your own
evaluation form, below is a list of common criteria. Select
categories/features and modify to meet your needs. You can also have your
students help by participating in the creation of an evaluation form.
Inventory of
Evaluation Categories/Features
INTRODUCTION
-
The speaker gains the audience's
attention and interest.
-
The speaker establishes his/her
credibility.
-
The speaker relates the topic to
audience
-
The speaker sets up central claim.
-
The central idea/main message is stated
at the beginning.
-
The speaker previews the presentation.
-
The whole talk is outlined early in the
presentation.
-
The introduction is brief in proportion
to the length of the talk.
-
The guiding research question is stated.
-
The importance of the research question
is stated.
-
The speaker establishes the significance of
topic for the audience.
BODY
-
The speaker relies on variety of
supporting materials.
-
If the methods are illustrated, a
matrix, flow chart, or other diagram is used.
-
The speaker uses sound reasoning.
-
The speaker uses main points to support
central idea.
-
The speaker uses supporting material to
substantiate main points.
-
Research methods are summarized in only enough detail to support the results.
-
The evidence is drawn from authoritative
sources.
-
The supporting material is relevant and
specific.
-
The speaker cites the source of the
evidence.
CONCLUSION
-
The speaker signals end of presentation
-
The speaker restates central idea
-
The speaker leaves a vivid impression of
presentation
-
The conclusions are stated at the end in
a form to reinforce the message.
-
The conclusions are concise.
GENERAL CONTENT
-
The speaker presents ideas in a clear
manner.
-
The speaker states one point at a time.
-
The speaker fully develops each point.
-
The presentation is cohesive.
-
The topic is appropriate.
-
The topic is worthwhile.
-
The presentation is properly focused.
-
A clear train of thought is followed and
involves the audience.
-
The speaker makes main points clear.
-
The speaker sequences main points
effectively.
-
The speaker includes internal summaries.
-
The outline is repeatedly referenced to
provide signposts.
-
The speaker provide effective signposts.
-
The speaker provides smooth transitions.
-
The format of graphs is described before
focusing on the content.
TIME
VISUAL AIDS
-
The speaker faces the audience while
speaking (speaker glances at the machine, not at the screen, while speaking).
-
The slides have large, readable text
(appropriate size for room).
-
Each slide makes only a single point.
-
There are five or fewer lines of text on
each slide.
-
Text is concise, having only a phrase or
a few words per line.
-
Background of slides is subordinate to
text.
-
Animation contributes to message instead
of distracting the audience.
-
Graphs are readable by all in the room.
-
Slides have been prepared specifically
for oral presentation.
DELIVERY/MECHANICS
-
The speaker does not read the
presentation.
-
The speaker does not apologize for the
presentation.
-
The speaker always faces the audience
when speaking.
-
The pointer is used as a precise
tool.
-
The speaker maintains strong eye contact.
-
The speaker gestures appropriately.
-
There are no unnecessary gestures or
distracting mannerisms.
-
The speaker effectively uses non-verbal
signals.
-
The speaker has good posture.
-
The speaker's facial expressions are
effective.
-
The speaker talks slowly and repeats key
ideas.
-
The speaker's voice can be clearly heard
by all in the room.
-
The speaker varies volume, pitch, and
rate.
-
The speaker uses pauses effectively.
-
The speaker varies the length of statements.
-
The speaker articulates and pronounces
words correctly.
-
The speaker demonstrates confidence.
-
The presentation is aimed at a specific
audience.
-
The presentation is adapted to address
the audience needs.
-
Language is free from unexplained jargon
and acronyms.
-
Language is appropriate to audience
-
Language is appropriate to topic is
concrete vivid and specific
-
Speaker uses alliteration, parallel
phrasing, imagery, or other rhetorical devices
-
The talk has been practiced to refine
the flow, message, and length.
QUESTION AND ANSWER OR DISCUSSION
SESSION
-
The speaker carefully listens to
questions.
-
The speaker asks for clarification of
the question when needed.
-
The speaker answers the questions that
are asked.
-
The speaker answers succinctly.
-
The speaker provides clear answers to
questions.
Evaluating student presentations: Written feedback from peers
Students learn critical thinking and listening skills by completing written
evaluations of peer performances. The evaluation forms above can be modified to
become student peer evaluation forms. It is sometimes helpful to have students
complete peer evaluations anonymously, to insure the most useful and honest
feedback.
Sample: Informative Presentation Peer Evaluation Form
- web page format Sample: Informative Presentation Peer Evaluation Form
- Acrobat (PDF) for easy printing
Sample: Persuasive Presentation Peer Evaluation Form
- web page format Sample: Persuasive Presentation Peer Evaluation Form
- Acrobat (PDF) for easy printing
Listening & Providing Feedback (PowerPoint
presentation)
PowerPoint
Viewer from Microsoft - download free viewer if you do not have
PowerPoint software.
Evaluating student presentations: Oral feedback from the teacher
Oral evaluation may include both positive comments and areas for improvement.
Like feedback on any assignment, it is helpful to offer constructive
criticism without personally attacking the character of the speaker.
Beebe and Beebe (2003) suggest the following to teachers and students for
providing oral or written feedback of oral presentations:
-
Be descriptive. Describe what you observed the speaker doing rather than
passing judgment. e.g. Say "I did not hear a concluding statement"
rather than "That was a stupid way to end your presentation."
-
Be specific. Give the speaker enough information so that she/he can improve
for the next presentation. e.g. Say "I would increase the font size on your
PowerPoint slides because I had trouble reading the slides" rather than
"Your visual aids were ineffective."
-
Be positive. "Sandwich" comments such that you begin with a
positive comment, then offer suggestions for improvement, and end with a
positive comment.
-
Be constructive. Give specific suggestions for improvement rather than simply
telling the speaker what they did wrong.
-
Be sensitive. Use tactful language in giving feedback rather than offering
blunt suggestions or comments. e.g. Say "Speak a bit louder so those in the
back of the room can hear you" rather than "I couldn’t hear a word
you said -speak up!"
-
Be realistic. Give the speaker feedback about things that he/she can actually
change. Telling a speaker that she/he is too short is not helpful.
10. References/Bibliography
Beebe, S.A., & Beebe, S.J. (2003). Public speaking: An
audience-centered approach. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
Lucas, S.E. (2001). The art of public speaking, 7th ed.
Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
McCroskey, J.C. (1982). An Introduction to Rhetorical Communication, 4th
ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Richmond, V.P., & McCroskey, J.C. (1998). Communication: Apprehension,
avoidance, and effectiveness, 5th ed.. Boston, MA: Allyn &
Bacon.
Schaller, K. (2002). Principles of effective public speaking: Student
workbook. Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill.
|